Tim-
My answer? I would have found a more seasoned host, with no history in the market. They lost the only show that was pulling decent numbers when Howie passed. They HAD the opportunity to rebuild. They replaced him with a CALLER. I've said Denning was a good choice for howies audience, but a missed opportunity. Jim stumbles, stammers, is uninformed of the facts, can't handle when a caller challenges him, and frankly is not very intelligent. (just like Erickson, a parody of a talk show) Bill Hall would have been a great hire, but not if attempting to change the sound.
They are only attempting to maintain, not increase or turnover their audience. Here was the opportunity to steal audience away from stations like WONE, and they blew it. These guys sound like the same old tired WNIR. There was no rebrand, no new sizzle. I'll give you an example. MIX 106.5 was dying on the vine in Cleveland. They changed the name, play about 80% of the same music and guess what happened? Their numbers shot thru the roof.
Im not sure why when we challenge what the local guys are doing, you mention clear channel or CBS or Cumulus. One has nothing to do with the other, despite your attempts. (especially sales managers and local sellers, when we are talking about programming, and you'd be surpised how little national revenue hits markets 50+.
ACME installed a load of self checkouts and laid off a bunch of employees. Was that somehow Clear Channels fault too because they started voice tracking?