Re: WOBM, G Rock Radio, WCHR, and the Alternative format
> > This is perhaps true, but it can't be denied that System
> Of
> > A Down's "B.Y.O.B." and Mudvayne's "Happy?" were rather
> > popular Modern Rock hits in 2005 - songs that G Rock, of
> > course, didn't touch, because they were too busy playing
> Eve
> > 6, Stroke 9, Republica or some other irrelevant one hit
> > wonder.
>
> Yes, SOAD and Mudvayne did well on the Alternative chart,
> but let's look at how the Alternative chart reporters are
> doing: For the most part, not well. If I'm an Alternative
> PD, why would I want to follow a bunch of other stations
> that are failing? It's similar to how the CHR chart was in
> the early-mid 90's.
>
> There's one common thread between all the rock stations that
> are doing well right now and that's that they're accessible.
> They play the hits and eliminate the songs, like SOAD and
> Mudvayne, that are an instant tuneout for older and female
> audiences during the daytime. (G-Rock does play SOAD at
> night.) G-Rock is far from alone in this. In Philadelphia,
> MMR has added Coldplay, Weezer, and the Killers, while
> ignoring SOAD. In Washington, DC101 has added back old Goo
> Goo Dolls hits, while limiting their currents to less than
> 20 songs.
>
> Playing "extreme rock" doesn't work anymore; it was too
> narrow a niche. Every successful rock station is trying to
> broaden its appeal, by adding songs with more appeal to
> older and female audiences, while limiting the hard stuff.
>
> There are still quite a few stations that are heavy on
> Disturbed, Mudvayne, and the like, stations like
> WXDX/Pittsburgh, WEDG/Buffalo, and WHRL/Albany. I'll leave
> it as an exercise to the reader to go check how those
> stations are doing in the Arbitrons, and what kind of
> listeners those stations get (hint: lots of male teens). In
> your area, stations like WYSP and WJSE are playing the music
> you're suggesting, and they're not doing well with it. You
> might just want to grab yourself an XM, tune to channel 48,
> and rip the knob off, because terrestrial radio isn't going
> to swing back towards nu-metal for a long time.
>
> Plus, I think you're not giving the G-Rock crew enough
> credit for breaking music. It may not be the music you
> want, but they've taken chances on up-and-coming artists
> that do appeal to their audience, artists like the Living
> Things, Matisyahu, and She Wants Revenge.
>
Credit is definitely due, no doubt about that. G Rock Radio has improved by leaps and bounds when it comes to their selection of currents - this is true. And that's probably because they don't have shallow infantile bands like Nickelback and 3 Doors Down hogging up all the top spots on their playlist right now (alas, there's still Fall Out Boy and Weezer's weak new material ... a whole chorus strung together from a bunch of whoa-ohs - that's so amazing ... but that's another rant). The one area that I would really like to see G Rock Radio improve at is with their library. I think everyone who listened to the Retro Rocktober weekend and FM 106.3 knows that they have a vast music catalog, and I know for a fact that they are not taking full advantage of it. You know how it's been said that humans only use a small percentage of their brains? I would estimate that G Rock Radio uses about 5 to 10% of its music catalog, instead pounding the same tired hits by Red Hot Chili Peppers, Green Day, Blink 182, Pearl Jam (only the first three albums, mind you), Nirvana (only Nevermind and Unplugged), and even bands the format has forgotten or barely played, like No Doubt, Tonic, and neo-classic rockers, the friggin' Black Crowes (?)! They loosen up just a little bit after 7 PM, but the change isn't all that drastic - maybe 1 in every 5 or 6 songs will be something that isn't played during the day. When it comes to their catalog, they're safe and hit-intensive to the point that it turns some listeners off. Now Indie 103.1 and WFNX - these are stations that have a much broader playlist and are more exciting for fans of the Alternative format. Yes, you can argue that these station aren't doing huge ratings, but you have to consider the competition in those cases - of which G Rock Radio has none, as their "The Only Alternative" tagline proclaims.</P>
On a related note, not only is G Rock Radio safe in their artist selections, but they're safe with song selections as well. 9 out of 10 times, if they play a Soundgarden song, it's going to be "Black Hole Sun". What, do you think listeners are going to run away screaming if you played "Outshined", "Blow Up The Outside World", or "Spoonman"? Ditto for Radiohead, with "Creep". This is the band that Coldplay owes their success to, and it stuns me that they get such infrequent airtime. And don't even get me started with how Depeche Mode and Morrissey get such limited play, because G Rock's too busy playing mentally challenged ape rockers like Puddle Of Mudd or acts like Fall Out Boy that are better suited for play at a child's birthday party.</P>
Forgive me. I'm a "glass is half-empty" person. I tend to see the negative before the positive. Criticisms aside, it's good to have a commercial Alternative station in the Monmouth/Ocean market. Of course, there's nothing to satisfy our hunger for edgier rock, becuase we don't get WJSE here, WYSP is now something like "50% Talk, 40% Sports, and 10% Rock - much of it softer, I might add", and WRAT is surprisingly not all that edgy either - they've yet to add a few tracks in the Active Rock Top 20 (Thousand Foot Krutch, Sevendust) and they ignore bands like Slipknot and Static-X in favor of a lot of the blues-based classic rock that other stations are playing, which IMO has led to their decline in ratings. There was a time where I said that I probably would not bother checking out satellite radio, but as time goes on, it begins to look all the more attractive - not having to please advertisers gives them the ability to offer something for everyone, and in a market like this where options are limited, I also see XM and Sirius gaining popularity in this area.</P>