The only '60s song remaining, or the last '60s song to "age out," at quite a few classic hits stations. The mystery of this middling 1967 hit's seemingly timeless appeal has been discussed at length on these forums, with no real answer other than "it still tests well." But why?
I'm such a nerd. I love opportunities like this to do some research. Granted, I did all this research in three minutes and utilized only one source, but still...
"Brown Eyed Girl" was released 5+ years before I was, but I know a good song when I hear one, and it's a darn good song. I'm also not sure I agree that peaking in the top 10 (albeit, at #10) is "middling." 😋
Since I was wondering about its chart performance, I headed over to the all-knowing, always-trusted, as-we-all-know-never-wrong Wikipedia, where I found that the song also managed to peak at #18 on Billboard's Hot Ringtones chart in 2006, nearly four decades after it was released. That may suggest that the song has some appeal to younger demos, as it wasn't likely a bunch of 60-year-olds who landed it on a
ringtones chart!
It's also been covered and/or performed by tons of other artists, including Adele, Everclear, Bruce Springsteen, and U2. Not exactly artists you'd find in the clearance bin with the likes of Susan Boyle and Los Del Rio.
As recently as 2010 (which is the blink of an eye in music history), the song had been included on multiple lists, such as Rolling Stone's "500 Greatest Songs of All Time," the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame's "500 Songs that Shaped Rock and Roll," BMI's "Top 100 Songs of the Century," and "100 Greatest Pop Songs" (compiled by Rolling Stone and MTV).
It obviously still tests very well if it's making it onto 300-song libraries in 2022. And really, does anyone actually
dislike the song? (Blue-eyed people don't count.)
Counterpoint: Among those who may also wonder about the song's lasting appeal might be Van Morrison himself: "It's not one of my best. I mean I've got about 300 songs that I think are better." (The bitter taste could also be because he was cheated out of any royalties for writing and recording the song.)
Apologies to fans of Susan Boyle and Los Del Rio.