Funny...I was just thinking about that myself the other day. I worked at a AAA station several years ago that was hugely successful, and continues to perform very well today. The thing with that format though, is you really have to know what you're doing musically. I've heard stations in many markets sign one on, and when I listen, I can tell that they don't "get it," and most of those barely keep their heads above water.
I would think it could work in the Dayton market, but the programmers have to be passionate about it and really know what they're doing. I don't think it's a format you just flip on and expect it to do well on auto-pilot.