I am in my late 70's and have no interest in the Big Bands and the crooners of the 40's and 50's. And among the kids I went to school with until I left Cleveland, there was nobody who raved about Sinatra or liked the pre-Top 40 songs.
In fact, a common complaint about our Top 40 stations like WERE and WHK was that they'd play some songs "that only grandma would like". But it was easy to flip between 1300 and 1420 (and occasionally 850 or even 1100) that we'd just ignore those songs.
So my experience says that there are few under 80 who like that old music. Yes, there are some but not a viable group for multiple reasons, starting with the fact that advertisers are not attracted to that group unless they are in The Villages or the like.
I occasionally converse with people from my own generation, and one of the rather general facts is that most don't want to relive the past. There may be a few old TV shows they like, but after 10 or 12 episodes of Gunsmoke, that itch is cured. And lots of songs we loved sound dated, corny and just old.
And really, really old listeners. You can't program a station based on music from wayback that a few people of newer generations have taken a liking to.
Thanks for mentioning in response to another post about a show that played big band music. I was a huge listener at the time when Dan Karcher came on board and hosted “Stardust Memories” which ran from November 2021 until around January 2022 where he was being let go. I missed Dan Karcher so much.
After his departure, I flipped to WCBS-FM and listened to Race Taylor for a while playing 80’s music without playing big band, and then Bob O on WGNY-FM’s “Fox Oldies”, and then JJ Carter on WBPM, Sunny Joe Allen on “Fox Oldies” and back to Race Taylor on WCBS-FM.
After two years of not having a Big Band type show, guess what? I switched to Mike McGann on WLML’s “Legends 100.3”, and I love his show, and this is where he plays big band music the way Dan Karcher played on WRCR, and it’s great to have big band music back to middays following a 2-year hiatus and I called it the “All New Stardust Memories” with Mike McCann”, and I am listening to it now. I started listening to it since April 1st which was last month and it’s started to get better.
It has Frank Sinatra, Tony Bennett, Sammy Davis Jr., Dean Martin, Ella Fitzgerald, Bobby Darin, and more to the limelight. I hope my favorite midday show “Stardust Memories” will be my #1 midday show after it took over for Race Taylor from WCBS-FM where they played too much 80’s music.
Like I said, I was a huge listener of “Stardust Memories” with Dan Karcher back in late 2021 until the last show in early 2022, and now I’m a huge listener of Mike McGann’s midday show with the return of “Stardust Memories”.