audioguy said:I like the idea of the shortened verticals for low power AMs. I also like the idea of letting stations with translators sign off their AM signals and only operate the translator. Many stations that have translators are only promoting their FM frequencies and probably most of their listeners are on FM, so what is the purpose for keeping the AM on the air when nobody is listening to it and it's just cluttering up the band?
I think you have to take what steps you can to limit the extent to which speculators buy up cheap AM stations & use them as a route to commercial LPFM. Maybe, you leave the AM on the books but waive the minimum operating schedule for the AM side, so the translator(s) have to stay within the hypothetical AM coverage & can't move into the nearest large market.
But really, yes, in most of these cases there's little point in leaving the AM on once there's a translator.
On the other hand, there is a definite need for small signal AMs where there are no FM frequencies available. At lower power levels (e.g., 100W or less), these stations would not pose that much of a threat of skywave interference at night. The amount of additional high-angle radiation from a shortened monopole is not that much greater than from a 1/4-wave monopole. Radiation patterns can be found in antenna textbooks. Some (limited) information is available in the ARRL Antenna Handbook. The ARRL Antenna Compendium series has a lot of good information, and I particularly like the Low-Band DXing handbook by John DeVoldere.
Good point about ON4UN's book, which I actually have but haven't cracked open in way too long...
To be honest I'm not convinced, about skywave from less-than-100-watt stations not being a significant issue. I mean, if it was just one small station it'd probably not be a big deal. With a few dozen of them it's a different story.
Unfortunately, really there will never be enough spectrum for every place that could use a station to have one. To be honest I suspect most of the places that wouldn't be served due to lack of low-power FM frequencies also don't generate enough economic activity to support a locally-operated station. I would have no objection to WGN's coverage area in Kansas being infringed by a small local station providing local service to Stockton. On the other hand, if that little station in Stockton, Kansas can't afford enough staff to do anything but carry national programs off the satellite... well, the people of Stockton would be just as well off hearing the same programs on KFAB.
I don't necessarily buy the idea that it's a good idea to shut down all of the low power AM stations and just have a few higher powered stations left. This leaves very little opportunity for programming diversity and many small communities that could have a radio voice are denied that voice. Consider the example of Kovas Communications which bought out three small town stations and shut them down so they could increase the power of their Evanston station on 1590. Those three communities lost their local radio service, which was replaced by a foreign language time-brokered station that provides only a very weak signal in those outlying areas (Harvard, East Chicago, and Aurora) and that more than likely is of no interest to listeners there anyway. In my opinion, it is a travesty that FCC rules permit things like this to happen.
I should say, just to be clear I'm not suggesting we forcibly close down any small AMs against their will. I think we shouldn't have licensed daytimers in the first place, but once someone has gone to the trouble to create and maintain one for a few decades, we really can't take it away from them.
I think what bothers me is when I see a small station being propped up with national programming that could be just as easily found on any number of other stations in the same area. These stations aren't serving their local public; they are making it more difficult for other stations to serve *their* publics. Maybe if we can tip the scales -- provide some incentive for those who are thinking about hanging it up to do so -- we can clear up the band for the survivors, without driving out the Howard Millers who are still interested & still serving.