What I remember was WTAE was a lot less stuffy. Their hosts tended to be more liberal (Lynn Cullen, for instance) but were more apt to talk lighthearted stuff whereas KDKA prided themselves on more serious conversation.
One of the more interesting sidebars was that KDKA was the Pirates and Penguins station, whereas WTAE was Steelers and Pitt. Perhaps because they were more in tune to the serious conversation I spoke of KDKA never really built a true sports talk show, save for the weekly "Sports Huddle" show built primarily around Bill Currie's irreverence.
The idea, I suppose, was that John Cigna was a sports fan so he could hold a conversation, and Perry Marshall was a guy who often spent the hours before his show at the ballpark so he could talk Pirates as well. And give them credit- it wasn't uncommon for them to have on guests such as Chuck Tanner. One year Marshall even went to the West Coast with the team and did his show from whatever California locale they were playing that day with the Pirates guests coming on after the game.
But no, it wasn't the same as listening to Myron Cope or Stan Savran, and that's a primary reason how WTAE earned their reputation as a sports station which would eventually lead to their flip to all sports in the late '90s.
Another guy who filled this sort of role on KDKA was Chris Cross. Though officially a "general" talk host, focused primarily on the Pirates and may have been very influential in keeping them in town during this dark period of the franchise. We even had the former KDKA GM come on here and reveal how Cross helped bring Bob Prince back to the KDKA booth.
But Cross also was lighthearted. Whether that led to him moving on to other locales- I don't know. I know he later hosted a post-game show from Chicago after White Sox games and the last I heard he was doing some play-by-play of things like University of Kentucky women's basketball.
But after that, from about 1986 or so after the Pirates and Penguins games talk show hosts came on who ignored them. One host even said on the air he didn't know if a baseball was inflated or stuffed.
Hence, if you wanted post-game talk, one generally flipped over to WTAE to listen to George Von Benko, who hosted a sports talk show that followed Myron Cope and Stan Savran and lasted until 11 p.m.
The other interesting thing about this era was Doug Hoerth. Hoerth earned a reputation for being witty and fun to listen to on KDKA- he was truly in his prime then. But around 1983 or '84 he was let go in favor of City Councilwoman Michelle Madoff.
I remember many listeners calling up and complaining about this move.
Then, KDKA really put Hoerth on a yo-yo. They brought him back later to do weekends, and remember in this era Hoerth's pop culture tastes weren't that out of date as they would later become. I loved to listen to it; he was the first talk show host I ever heard that not only knew who Van Halen was, but professed to being a fan, and there was something about a guy who could entertain you by telling you what his favorite Mr. Ed episodes were when Mr. Ed could still be seen in reruns.
He could even hold a conversation if one wanted to talk about the Pens or, believe it or not, the emerging pro wrestling boom of the time. Perhaps it's not a surprise, then, that Mark Madden has said Hoerth was one of his primary influences.
But then Hoerth was demoted to doing weekend overnights on KDKA. Finally, he went to WTAE, where he really shined and found a home for a decade and never resisted an opportunity to call KDKA stuffy.
Another guy WTAE took from KDKA, kinda, was Bruce Keidan. A sports columnist who often co-hosted with Cross, he was later the Wed-Friday sports talk show host during Cope's semi-retirement around 1989 to 1994 or so at 1250.
That was an odd mix, because for half the week there was Cope, who was humorous and down-to-earth, and for the rest of the week there was Keidan, who tried to be intellectual, was not going to root for the teams on the air the way Cope did, and could even be a bit of a wise guy at times.
In terms of personality, Myron was the grandpa who bought you ice cream and took you to the park, while Keidan was the one who wanted to know how you did on your report card.
To me, the one guy at WTAE who might have fit at KDKA was Phil Musick. Very in tune to what was going on in all of Pittsburgh, he was the knowledgable everyman in terms of persona.
Ironically, the one survivor of that era today, other than Stan Savran of course, is probably KDKA's Dimitri, who did weekends for WTAE in the early 90s.
Final note- WTAE was actually the first station in Pittsburgh to carry Rush Limbaugh, circa 1990 or so. He was delayed and played on weekends as he was beginning to make it big and there was a lot of buzz about his show locally even then. Talk radio, at that point, was not the hard right wing ground it is today.
When I first posted on here one of the first topics I asked was "What if WTAE had kept Rush Limbaugh and put him live on weekdays?" Would they still be a general talk station? Could they have beaten KDKA?
I know one of the points made was that Rush always was looking for the top dog station in town so he would have eventually left for KDKA, just as he did leave KDKA for 104.7 in 2005 or so.
But I wonder, even if he did, could he have helped secure enough footing for WTAE to be the younger man's talk station (remember, Rush was only 38 or so at the time), thus staying on at WTAE for several years? Would WTAE then continue on as a general talk station and be more of a successful ratings gainer (my memory has WTAE netting ratings in the 3.0-4.0 range in the early '90s, whereas KDKA was more than double that)?
Could it have been KDKA eventually woulda become the sports station?
Who knows? But for me, the demise of WTAE as a general talk station was probably not realizing what they had there (ya run Sally Jesse every day after the sports shows but not Rush as he's becoming an icon?), firing Stan Savran, and the retirement of Myron Cope.