Yep,...this has become a two-sided discussion, and that is quite healthy. The post before this one, from snailboy, has a very valid point. He is OK with a Thick Playlist, as long as it is properly maintained. That point is pure truth because we all have heard large playlists that have not been maintained, even to the point of obvious neglect. Giving songs a shelved rest has always been one of my Programming practices. At the last AOR, that I Programmed, I even went a step further, and shelved some songs as "Seasonal". "Forever Autumn" by Justin Heyward only ran October thru February. It may sound a bit silly, but I felt that it was just important to hold, as it was to control the rotation. Some songs like "Red, Red Wine", are just "Deadwood", and should have been deleted years ago. That song has zero benefit for MAGIC 98.9 Judging from how much they play it, just smacks a pencilneck Consultant, with the printed results of an Auditorium Music Test, to justify his paycheck. One of the biggest Lies in the Business. Trust me, the song is dead, and this is why their ratings are so small. It's just the Truth!