I'm sure that the Christmas stations of the UK's Heart and the Netherlands' Sky Radio continue to play Christmas music on Halloween.How about those 24/7/365 streams on the internet that play Christmas music every day of the year? (Except during Halloween, of course.)
No, that's next year. This year, Hanukkah starts on the evening of December 7.Both holidays are on the same day this year.
My bad but there should be some more focus on Chanukah songs. It should be holiday music and one is hard pressed to hear a Chanukah song. I’m sure I’m not the only Jewish listener of WLTW 😎.No, that's next year. This year, Hanukkah starts on the evening of December 7.
If there were any Chanukah songs that were commercially viable, you’d probably hear them. To my knowledge, Adam Sandler is really about the only “artist” that fits that description.My bad but there should be some more focus on Chanukah songs. It should be holiday music and one is hard pressed to hear a Chanukah song. I’m sure I’m not the only Jewish listener of WLTW 😎.
There are some others. They are hard to find but they are thereIf there were any Chanukah songs that were commercially viable, you’d probably hear them. To my knowledge, Adam Sandler is really about the only “artist” that fits that description.
Not to mention that Hanukkah and Christmas are not comparable holidays. Christmas is either the most or second-most (behind Easter) important holiday in Christianity. Hanukkah is, at best, fourth behind Yom Kippur, Rosh Hashanah and Passover. Its reputation as the "Jewish Christmas" is largely due to envy by Jewish children of their Christian friends' annual holiday haul and the resulting accommodation by their parents.If there were any Chanukah songs that were commercially viable, you’d probably hear them. To my knowledge, Adam Sandler is really about the only “artist” that fits that description.
But given the holidays happen at similar times of the year why can’t they call it holiday music. It is not fair for Jewish people like myself that want some of our music to also be represented. Shouldn’t there be some parity? I’m not making this a religious debate but I feel a bit offended that the stations (WLTW, WKJY and WALK) all do the same.Not to mention that Hanukkah and Christmas are not comparable holidays. Christmas is either the most or second-most (behind Easter) important holiday in Christianity. Hanukkah is, at best, fourth behind Yom Kippur, Rosh Hashanah and Passover. Its reputation as the "Jewish Christmas" is largely due to envy by Jewish children of their Christian friends' annual holiday haul and the resulting accommodation by their parents.
Chanukah is not Jewish Christmas. It commemorates that the single day of oil in the temple lasted 8 daysNot to mention that Hanukkah and Christmas are not comparable holidays. Christmas is either the most or second-most (behind Easter) important holiday in Christianity. Hanukkah is, at best, fourth behind Yom Kippur, Rosh Hashanah and Passover. Its reputation as the "Jewish Christmas" is largely due to envy by Jewish children of their Christian friends' annual holiday haul and the resulting accommodation by their parents.
As a largely non-observant Jew (I'm in it mainly for the food and the jokes.), I don't care if Adam Sandler or whoever else might be doing Hanukkah music ever gets played on my local AC station. We're only 2 percent of the U.S. population. Not only that, In less than 20 years, according to statistical studies, there are going to be more Muslims than Jews in this country. Eid music, anyone? Let the majority have its way on this. Nobody's getting proselytized by Burl Ives or Nat King Cole, after all.But given the holidays happen at similar times of the year why can’t they call it holiday music. It is not fair for Jewish people like myself that want some of our music to also be represented. Shouldn’t there be some parity? I’m not making this a religious debate but I feel a bit offended that the stations (WLTW, WKJY and WALK) all do the same.
There is a decent Jewish population in Market 1 and there should be more representation. I don’t want to make it a debate but those of us who feel this way should contact those stations and request more Chanukah songs to be played.
I don't know whether to laugh or admire this post, as it's a welcome change from the usual yes/no Christmas music discussions, usually participated by men who a) won't listen anyway and b) men who don't listen to the station that goes "all Christmas" during the rest of the year anyway.As a largely non-observant Jew (I'm in it mainly for the food and the jokes.), I don't care if Adam Sandler or whoever else might be doing Hanukkah music ever gets played on my local AC station. We're only 2 percent of the U.S. population. Not only that, In less than 20 years, according to statistical studies, there are going to be more Muslims than Jews in this country. Eid music, anyone? Let the majority have its way on this. Nobody's getting proselytized by Burl Ives or Nat King Cole, after all.
I generally don't listen to AC anyway, so very little of the pop holiday/seasonal music ever reaches my ears. I do enjoy classical Christmas music and traditional carols sung by choirs very much, regardless of message, and you will find me with SiriusXM's Holiday Pops channel streaming as background music at home fairly often during December. Hark, Joy to the World, Adeste Fideles, The First Noel, Handel's Messiah .... all wonderful pieces of music that beat the living schmaltz out of The Dreidl Song every day of the week and twice on Saturday. Hanukkah music on FM ... bah humbug.
We have been advised not to discuss songs, our opinion of songs, or what songs we do or don't want to listen to on OTA radio or streaming radio.Hey guys, it's August and we're only about 3 and a half months away from the flip to Christmas music!!! That being said, every year they play the same 10 songs, and different versions of the same songs, pretty much every hour!! What songs would you like to see them add this year? What songs would you like to see them cut?
Generally, the target for AC stations that do "All Christmas" is Women 25-54, with the core being 35-54.We have been advised not to discuss songs, our opinion of songs, or what songs we do or don't want to listen to on OTA radio or streaming radio.
We have been told: If a station is playing a certain song, then it has been tested on the audience by an auditorium music test, to which the potential listeners responded favorably. So, if the station is playing the same 10 Christmas songs, it is because those are the songs that the listeners indicated that they wanted to hear. So, our opinion of a song doesn't matter ( especially if we are over 45 years old), because programming is quantitatively and scientifically determined by statistics.
At the risk of being didactic: remember, Mexico is part of North America. So what you really mean is the US and Canada.In North America, December holidays are traditionally built around the season of winter and the idea of cozy home gatherings.
That is a good observation. And it fits with the core of most stations that do the Christmas music marathon... AC stations that target those same women all year long.But the traditional work of preparing a family home for the holidays -- and this includes, Christmas, Chanukah, Festivus, and Kwanzaa, is assigned to women. All these holidays encompass gathering in a warm home to celebrate togtherness of friends and family. Because women spend more time working on holiday preparations, they may tune in more to all-Christmas radio stations while they are getting ready, or shopping online, or baking, or decorating, or any one of hundreds of tasks required/ expected of women in North America to prepare a family for the holidays.
¡Muchas gracias!I understand why Latin America does not do this, and David has explained this very well.
I know a lot of women in my family who love the Great American Family and who used to like Hallmark until they got "woke" and forgot that the largest minority group in America is Hispanic. What they like is that the stories, as artificial and corny as they are, reflect family values that are deep in the Latin American tradition. For the same reason, so many Hispanics, as they become part of America, love Thanksgiving which is also a celebration of the "Great American Family".... and why they don't celebrate the "Drink-o de Mayo" which is everything but a family occasion.It's not that only women have hopelessly awful, despicable taste in music which is mawkishly sentimental, tear-jerking crap, or maudlin emotionally-wrought taste in Hallmark channel Christmas movies which are absolute bull****. I don't think that is the reason. I think it is the social pressure that they are judged by whether or not they can produce a spectacular holiday experience and live up to the expectations of North American society.
At the risk of being didactic: remember, Mexico is part of North America. So what you really mean is the US and Canada.