^ I understand that Merv Griffin did not want Fleming anymore, because he envisioned the show running a long time (which it did), and they wanted someone younger. Now Trebek is 69, right? Anyway, after a few shows, I am sure everybody forgot about Fleming.
One thing Trebek can do that Fleming didn't, was to "clear the board" often. Fleming did a lotta ad-libbing in between "correct questions," like ribbing Don Pardo, singing a little bit if a musical clue, etc....and there was still clues remaining when the round was over.
I think that it's quite a tribute that Trebek can do this, especially since commercial time has increased! (not to mention the long taped time of "Clue Crew" clues)
cd
Trebek is 71 now, and as it is, Fleming would not have survived the new version for many years; I think he died in 1995.
I'm sure there's a whole generation who thinks Trebek has been the only host of "Jeopardy!" and that's understandable, although at first he took some negative comparisons to Fleming...until people got used to him. Actually, although I personally liked Fleming better, I think Trebek is better hosting "Jeopardy!" simply because he moves the game along without all the ad-libbing, giving the contestants more opportunities to add to their scores. (He would be perfect for "GE College Bowl" if somebody revived it, since he hosted the high-school quiz bowl "Reach For The Top" in Canada.)
Merrill Heatter, when Trebek was hosting "High Rollers" and Wink Martindale was doing "Gambit," wasn't quite so complimentary of Trebek. "Wink gives it a 'Music Man' approach," Heatter said, meaning in essence that if the contestants and audience are having a good time, then so is the Winker. "Alex simply moves the game along...he doesn't put his arm around nervous contestants...he doesn't care if they're having a good time."
But Art Fleming wasn't too unhappy about being overlooked for the new "Jeopardy!". As he told one interviewer, "In my day, everybody kept their winnings; now, only the winner keeps the cash" (this was before the change that gave $2000 to the second-place player and $1000 to the third-place one).