Looking at JayF's musical crispy critter nominees, these songs get played the hell out of in Buffalo but I don't think I've heard them on-air in a long time in Rochester...
Whispers-Rock Steady
Tina Turner-What's Love Got To Do With It
B52s-Love Shack
Gnarles Barkley-Crazy
Seal-Kiss from A Rose
Got a feeling that some songs which are charcoal in one market may be still welcomed by Rochester listeners, and a few (like Seal's Kiss from a Rose) might even generate an 'oh, wow" moment from some...
Some songs are burned to a crisp everywhere, like Hotel California or Footloose. But burnout could very well be a regional thing for some songs more than 10 years old--remember, it's only in the last 10 years or so that playlists on most stations came from a central group programming office, and songs burned out at the same time everywhere. Up through the late 90s local PDs had a lot more leeway in crafting their playlists, and deciding how many songs to keep in the recurrent bin. Today it's national and uniform, and the recurrent bins keep a lot of the same songs on the air past their shelf life everyplace...