"You really need to stop with this nonsense. You have newbies confused and it really drags down the overall sensibility of this board!"
Friendly advide to luvcoors; You might do well to keep your flame wars to yourself. They don't do anything constructive in this board.
The purpose of this board is to exchange ideas, including some that may be "out of the box" and therefore a little unorthodox. But you and many others forget that out-of-the-box thinking is what has made a lot of stations successful and moved this business forward. It's the reluctance of today's suits in the front office that have put the broadcasting business into what's now a multi-year state of decline.
Having said that, there are some puzzling assertions in your post. Where you got a #1 ranking for Buzz is beyond me...they are a successful station and no one including me is suggesting it make major changes, but #1? Don't think so, that's WBEE's turf. And saying PXY is #3 with women 12+ (as you must be implying, since you don't qualify further) looks to me to be mathematically very difficult with an overall 12+ AQH that doesn't crack a 5 share, unless the male audience is close to zero (and I can't believe that's the case). By the way, PXY had its second weakest book in years, it's a full share point below where it was 12 months ago.
PXY is an obvious candidate for change since it's long past its prime and way underperforming for a full-B signal. You wouldn't put Tony and Dee on a CHR signal; had you read my earlier post closely, I'm saying they ought to give up that format fight given the heavy competition in their 12-34 target demos, and try to take on a bigger and more lucrative target demo where the traditional main player is on the ropes and vulnerable by flipping to an older-skewing sound to reclaim the people who grew up with it in the 80s and are now floating around looking for a station to call home.
CMF might be an even bigger candidate for change, since its numbers are now about 30% below the level of 12 months ago.
"W 25-34 is the main goal!"
Let's say for the sake of argument that PXY has strength in that demo range. Is that a big enough demo that you can make sufficient money with that alone? Don't you need the 35-54 women who are now clearly in play and looking for a place to land now that Warm is shrinking?
Just thinking out loud, accept it for what you will, agree or disagree, but let's try to be agreeable even as we disagree...