fwmw and Tom Wells get what I'm saying. Using it in the mic as a jock and allowing it to play as recorded in a song are completely different things. Furthermore, allowing it to play in some songs (say, from The Eagles) is easier to get by with than in others (say, from Marilyn Manson).
I will agree that, 99.9% of the time, using the phrase as a jock on the mic is next to impossible to defend. The other .1% of the time, there better be a visible tornado outside your studio window. Close.
But putting a blanket kybosh on a questionable phrase, for all uses in all contexts, just sounds bad. It's not like listeners don't notice edits like that. Even if you do edit it, it's not like they don't know what is being said.
What I've been saying is you have to use your head, know your audience, and know your format. Allowing "god damn" to play in a song on an oldies rock station in Salem is different from allowing it to play on an alt rock station in Gary.
As for you, MightyFrenchman, I may be young, but I've got a postgraduate degree in this and have worked in this state and others as everything from a mic monkey to an ND. So don't pull the "old timer" card on me.
I will agree that, 99.9% of the time, using the phrase as a jock on the mic is next to impossible to defend. The other .1% of the time, there better be a visible tornado outside your studio window. Close.
But putting a blanket kybosh on a questionable phrase, for all uses in all contexts, just sounds bad. It's not like listeners don't notice edits like that. Even if you do edit it, it's not like they don't know what is being said.
What I've been saying is you have to use your head, know your audience, and know your format. Allowing "god damn" to play in a song on an oldies rock station in Salem is different from allowing it to play on an alt rock station in Gary.
As for you, MightyFrenchman, I may be young, but I've got a postgraduate degree in this and have worked in this state and others as everything from a mic monkey to an ND. So don't pull the "old timer" card on me.