landtuna said:CTListener said:Natasha Bedingfield's and Colbie Caillat's songs would be first-rate pop confections regardless of the decade they came out.
That must be why those names are on the tip of everyone's tongue.
Not on the tongues of many people over, say, 24, granted, but that's the nature of the beast. Pop radio is so splintered today, and older generations so hostile to the music it plays, that the cross-generational recognition factor is much less than the '70s, when everyone know who Elton John was. As I said, times have changed. I'm 55 and neither like nor understand hip-hop, the dominant popular music form of the past decade-plus. But I can still see (and hear) why a pop ditty like "Unwritten" or a rock song of the past couple of years by acts like Daughtry and Green Day become hits. Are "Unwritten" and "Wake Me Up When September Ends" "better" than "He's So Fine" or "Takin' Care of Business"? I'd say no, but then, they're the songs of someone else's childhood and teenage years, not mine.
Yes, there are a great number of disposable acts in pop and rap today (and some of the rap acts are getting disposed of permanently), but hey, we had our Ohio Expresses and New Vaudeville Bands and Henry Grosses, right? Times change, tastes change, but really, nothing of substance has changed.