gr8oldies said:I hear you and yes I have seen local shows go syndicated and have a a watered down feeling. Mike McConnell took his weekday show syndicated from WLW and it wasn't the same. He never got much in the way of clearances and it's now local again. Gary Burbank, also of WLW, was syndicated for a time and dropped in the ratings in Cinncinati (if you're not familiar he did more in the way of comedy than straight talk though he could do it if there was a breaking story). Around that time all the Marge Schott (former Reds owner with a very un-PC mouth) stuff was happening and there was tons of material that wouldn't have translated nationwide. He came back to local-only until his retirement.
Having said that, I'm still not a believer in "local because it's local". I live in the Dayton area and I can't imagine being captivated three hours a day by the ins and outs of Dayton politics.
I wonder if Clear Channel is finally giving up on trying to nationalize WLW personalities now that Sean Compton is gone. Sean had always said WLW was his favorite station, and it still feels like a company flagship station despite Jacor having been acquired by Clear Channel. It's a great local station, and that's pretty much it. America's Trucking Network used to have a wider syndication base, but now it's one station away from being a local show again. The only way they've managed to get any of their hosts syndicated successfully is to have them inherit existing shows. Mike McConnell took over for The Weekend, and Bill Cunningham took over for Matt Drudge. The other way is to have them leave WLW.