First things first, great MD's that understand/understood dance music, there's two that I believe were the best in NY at identifying the hits. Andy Shane (Z100 & WKTU) and Paul "Cubby" Bryant (Z100). Both have amazing ears. Both could not just identify a dance hit but they could then make it happen.
There are a lot of other MD's in other markets that kick butt when it comes to picking the hits but these are two that I've had the pleasure of knowing for a long time and they are in my market so I stuck with the NY guys as they crossed records over.
Next, KTU switched as a direct result of a company owning a lot of stations in a market and needing to protect it's investments. KTU was switched to strengthen Z100's demos and to give back some of the older demos to Lite-FM. It's called cluster programming and if you don't know what it is then try to read up on it, it's unfortunately the here and now as well as the future.
As for programming a dance station today, you cannont ignore anyone under 50, especially women as they have a long history in most major markets with the music.
If dance music is going to make a comeback on the FM dial it needs to happen in two places. The first is the street (trendsetters, in NY the latino market). The second is with women. Women have always loved rhythmic dance music and they are still big supporters today. Ex: For the second year in a row in at Madison Square Garden a freestyle show sold out. Older women in this market still love that music and it would have to be a part of any station coming in.
How to get it to happen in the streets and with women is a totally different thread.
A properly run and dayparted FM could kick butt in NY. Playing Ferry Corsten in all dayparts isn't going to cut it. But playing Ferry Corsten after 6pm will. You almost have to program the station as if it were two. The day shift filled with the Pop remixes and familiar dance hits and then the night where you can add a slightly more of the clubbish vibe to it. I did this 20 years ago, on a small scale (10 watt station), and it worked with major results (weekly Cume of 250,000).
That said, I still don't believe that any current based dance station is coming into NY anytime soon. The folks at Corporate still don't get it. They don't understand the potential, they've never heard of the genre's stars, and you can't point to anything that indicates that we've had success on a sustained level. I mean, the biggest thing going in Dance right now is Tiesto and his sold out across america tour. Yet, he's only sold 60,000 albums. That my friends points to B-I-G problems for dance music.
jp