I think Kathy Bates is great, but I didn't care for the original version of the show. I might check out the new version, but maybe not...David E. Kelley's productions really irritate me, for the most part.
The last Kelley program I liked was The Practice - the show that morphed later into Boston Legal. The first season or two were well written, but I got sick of all the Kelley gimmicks - overwrought characters yelling at each other all the time, and the obligatory 'shocking twist' at the end.
I forced myself to watch one or two episodes of Boston Legal because it's always fun watching Shatner chew up the scenery, but that's about it.