Here's a few thoughts to respond to the previous posts. As far as Sunny 105.9 goes, the station/format was not always a ratings success. Almost similar to Jax, the format was started/stopped a number of times among a number of stations. Not only is this disruptive to listeners but it makes success even more elusive in the competitive world of radio. However, what Sunny had going for it was they had a company behind them vested in their success. A new PD was brought in and he was given latitude and certainly ample time to turn things around. Yes, there was trial and error and some things didn't work. Today, time and patience has created a win/win for both listeners and for the parent company. This doesn't happen too often in radio nowadays but how sweet it is when it does!
Magic 107.3 had a lot going for her. There was a very capable PD and a talent who knew this market and music inside and out. There was another who was a part of the CBS Radio culture and let's face it, they do the format very well. Their expertise and knowledge meant very little. Instead, decisions were made by someone who clearly was over his head. When I visit S. Fla I usually hook up with a number of radio friends there.Even they knew, the former PD brought in a year or so ago simply did not like the format. Still, I believed that given the former OM's brother was a brand coordinator for oldies/classic hits, I was really hopeful an effective level of support and attention would follow. Obviously, none of that happened. RIFs are a fact of life and still it's a shame the pain couldn't be spread around.
As far as the positioning of Magic goes, in no way was the intent to knock off Eagle. Magic was designed to be a more female friendly version of Eagle while also attracting some WEJZ listeners who weren't exactly turned on by contemporary music. Overall, Magic's ratings weren't the best but they were far better than many others doing the format. Magic actually beat Eagle in certain targets/demos. I can't help but think of Miami/South Florida. The hybrid oldies station there has been drifting and struggling for years. Yet, they are given another lifeline with the hiring of a new PD. We aren't so fortunate in Jax and there is a track record of not supporting the format in all 3 major radio groups.
Frustrated? You bet I am and it's because the powers that be in this market don't recognize the real demand that does exist. In my travels, besides S. Fla, I know some radio folks in the Northeast. Almost always the subject of radio in Jacksonville comes up in conversation. It's rare for them to bring up rock or country. But rather they talk about the mighty WAPE of the past when they would travel through Jax between NYC and Miami. A Top 40 popular music town - indeed we are- there is lots of history there and a big format bucket. For a number of years, when I would review ratings almost always the hit music stations to include retro formats such as Magic combined out-performed rock, country and urban at least in audience shares. To me, that says a lot.
Here we are in the July 4th holiday and summer is such a great time to listen to the radio. Locally, my radio is turned off. I do have 105.9 on my car presets and sometimes I'm treated to good radio, most times I am not. One of the biggest complaints I read on the boards are stations/brands like Eagle that play the same 300 songs over and over. I get why that happens because from a programming perspective it works. Indeed, Eagle is a successful brand. However, that format is limited and restricted as it generally presents one genre of music and it's the same old same old every single day.
We live in a wonderful age. I've been listening to CBS Radio's Oldies/Classic Hits WOGL over the past several days. They are presenting a Top 1000 countdown and it's great. There are so many wow songs, some I haven't heard on the radio since Cool 96.9 went away. In some ways, CBS Radio has almost taken a "Jack" approach with all the variety and genres of music presented. In a sea of sameness, I always saw so much opportunity in differentiating yourself more especially in weekend and holiday programming. CC just didn't have the same philosophy as CBS and I believe it could have made a difference here. So now there is Jack. Jack is cheap. Cheap trumps real listener demand. Happy 4th!