That would be novel. Maybe trend-setting. "You don't know the market" isn't an attack on your overall knowledge or acumen; you don't know the market nuance; just as we don't know the market nuance of San Juan, Quito or Cleveland (which so many people say "is just like Buffalo, but bigger." Cleveland is Cleveland, it isn't a bigger Buffalo.) Every market, whether it's your home base of Cleveland or Palm Springs has an undercurrent, a vibe, a history, even a seamy underbelly of the market. It can take countless months, even years, especially in Buffalo, to understand it.
I'll quote "Clarin" which is the largest newspaper in Argentina, with 1.2 million circulation when I worked there for Emmis:
"It took a foreigner to show (us) Argentines that we liked Argentine rock". That was after picking a format based on 3 days of observation in a market I had not been in for at least a decade, refining it with research from Edison, and going to a double-the-next-station #1 ratings in a single month.
My point, besides showing off my trophy, is that insiders, locals and seeming experts sometimes do that old "forest for the trees" thing.
In the Dominican Republic nobody thought that a personality morning show would work. I hired two guys who's main fame was each being fired from many of the principal stations in Santo Domingo, trained them one evening and launched the next day. That was in 1986, and the show has been #1 in every book since, even beating the ratings of the top prime time TV shows on many occasions.
So I'd say that Randy was successful because he was inspired, not because of where he was from. The inner flame was there, and would have burnt bright in Bismark, ND or New Iberia, LA.
The only thing I learned in Cleveland was how not to do radio, working at WJMO and WCUY. So where I was from was nearly irrelevant. I learned radio from WLS, WABC, WTIX, KOMA and the like. I got a quick course from Todd Storz days before he died. But what mattered was where I was, not what I had left.
I'll mention a phone call I had with the owner of a new station in Karachi: "But i don't know the language, the culture or the core religious beliefs". "Yes, but you know radio".
Sometimes fresh eyes keep things from growing old. Sometimes outsiders see St. Elmo's Fire where others see ashes.