Band-Scanner said:
WMGQ is in the unfortunate position of being in a "shadow" market of NYC with a strong signal from WLTW and now having to compete with Fresh as well.
WMGQ has much less coverage....WKJY in Long Island frequently interferes with them in the fringes.....even the Catskills station sometimes sneaks in....not to mention WOGL @ 98.1.
In order to survive they must "super serve" Central NJ and stop trying to be a regional music intensive station. Do more "local " news and announcements and become involved more with the core communities they serve.
Music format? That's a tough one....I would have to say Hot AC somewhere between WPLJ & WLTW ....gold leaning...like the breeze.
First of all, we're assuming that the 25-54 numbers for WMGQ are as mediocre as the 12+ numbers. I've not seen the 25-54's, so the station may be more stable than we think.
As far as the music you seem to be referring to, I would take a good look at a cross between the Breeze and WKQC/Charlotte. The Breeze has the variety, and WKQC plays a lot of 70's and 80's without sounding "old." Personally, I wouldn't go that route.
Here's the problem I have with the variety, gold-based approach. The Breeze can be received in some areas that Magic is listenable. WCBS-FM (now playing more 70's and 80's) is received in most of the area where Magic is. WMGQ would be caught between a rock and a hard place if they ever decided to take this route.
Maybe Hot A/C would work. 'PLJ seems to be very successful in Central Jersey. Magic should have tried "Fresh" before CBS Radio jumped on it. It seems that Fresh is taking off here as well. Jan Ochs, Tim Tefft, John Lisk, Staci Dee, Danni G all sound either tired or annoying. Steve O'Brien, Matt Newman and Alan David Stein were the best three WMGQ had. Now, only Newman remains, IIRC. I'm an advocate for personality radio... I really am. But when faced with "personalities" such as Tefft, Dee, and Lisk, I'd rather the station be jockless.
As you stated, Magic is in a "shadow" market. While "Central Jersey's Music Station" playing "Today's Hits and Yesterday's Favorites" may have worked in the 90's, the "Continuous Soft Rock" format is falling fast. They need a new format -- maybe just an updated AC somewhat similar to Fresh with a larger playlist, but not soft AC, not oldies. It has been proven that central Jerseyans prefer the NYC alternatives for Magic's current format and have done so for awhile.
Maybe an updated AC format could work without a major overhaul. All I know is they certainly haven't tried to change the station's image lately. The new commercial focuses on tired AC songs like "Crocodile Rock" and "Breakaway." EEK!
chuckydoll said:
Magic 98.3 has a history of being a copycat station. It continued to play 60's oldies after other AC stations dumped 60's music -- and this was when 101.1 was Jack.
60's oldies? Not really. They play many of the same limited 60's songs that WLTW played (and still plays). WMGQ rarely plays anything from the 60's, and hasn't for at least two years. You'll hear "Build Me Up Buttercup," "What a Wonderful World" and the like.
BOTTOM LINE: If their 25-54 numbers are as mediocre as their 12+ numbers, WMGQ needs help! Someone wake up and do something!