I agree no variety and very boring. The same 10 stations playing the same songs. We have 2 Hot A/Cs, 2 Hip Hop stations, 1 Classic Hip Hop station, 2 sports on FM, 1 news on FM, 2 Spanish Language Stations, 1 A/C, 1 Classic Rock, 1 Adult R&B station, 1 Conservative Talk Station, and 1 Christian Station (non-commercial).
Your numbers here are a bit off. Check your math.
We lack commercial stations including:
1. Alternative Rock
2. AAA
3. Country
4. Variety Hits
5. Oldies
1. We've discussed in the Alt 92.3 thread why that station failed, and why alt rock isn't coming back. Alt rock was poorly executed by a PD who thought he knew what he was doing, and corporate pushed the local management to put WINS on FM. iHeart is the only other real operator in town and all their stations are successful, so no chance.
2. Why do you need commercial AAA in the city proper when you, depending on where you are, can receive WXPK or WFUV?
3. NYC has had many attempts at country. The most recent attempt had one of the worst cumes of a music FM in the city. Can you give a reason for this format to exist in NYC other than "variety"?
4. This seems moot when you have a strong classic hits station, a strong AC, and a strong classic rock station. There is little leeway for a variety hits station to exist, let alone gain traction.
5. WABC airs some oldies on weekends, and there's 101.1 HD3. That's the closest you're gonna get to Oldies radio in NYC unless Catsimitidis buys another pet project AM.
1. 95.5 which was Hot A/C
2. 92.7 which was Spanish Language CHR.
1. WPLJ was a shell of itself when it died, and those listeners have moved on.
2. A station that, because of it's limited signal, did not gain traction and was majorly outmatched by it's main competitor in signal and thus ratings.