mjb1124 said:
When somebody has aged to the point where they are unable to do the job properly, then yes, they should be let go. It's not age discrimination - it's good business sense. If Imus was able to stay even half as sharp as he was in his heyday, he could stay on for another 20 years. But that is clearly not the case here.
Your point is well-taken, but I don't think this situation is as black and white (no pun intended) as you're making it.
If, indeed, someone can no longer do their job properly because of age, then certainly the demands of business do call for something to be done about that. However, I do not think that is anywhere near clear in the case of Imus. If you go back to as recently as the day before he made his comment about the Rutgers women's basketball team, you will find that the commentators, the media, and even the management of WFAN, CBS radio, and MSNBC had nothing but praise for Imus. He hosted the highest-grossing radio show in NYC, he brought stability and direction to the morning programming for a major cable network, and was a much-sought after guest on the cable TV talking heads shows. Then he made his fateful remark and everything came crashing down.
But, only a few months later, another major broadcasting chain offered him millions of dollars to host a syndicated morning show (and they knew how old he was when they made the offer). Your statement that he is clearly not half as sharp as he was 20 years ago is nothing more than subjective, if not downright inaccurate. Did his ability, his mind, his sense of humor, and his interviewing skills, decrease so substantially in barely a year? You certainly have the right to not like his show and, for that matter, to not like him, but I think you're way off base in your comments. Imus may not always have made the best decisions, but, overall, he's had a career that eclipses 99.9% of all those who have ever worked in radio...and that continues right through to today. Just look at the national attention he's getting this week. People who aren't very sharp don't get this kind of attention.
I don't think he's lost a step. In my opinion, he's just changed his style from 20 and 30 and 40 years ago (and even from last year as well). Any professional broadcaster would do that in order to survive in the ever-changing industry of radio. Someone like Imus, who has been at the top of his profession as long as he has, will know (and/or be told by those he respects) that it's time to hand over the reins. Certainly Citadel and WABC radio don't agree with your assessment. They're not in the business of throwing away money by giving it to those who can't cut it anymore.
Citadel is to be praised for judging their personnel on the basis of ability and talent (or lack thereof), rather than on how old they are.