You are so right about having the right antenna. There is a similar example of "The VHF DTV Problem" going on here in Kentucky. There is a station in Louisville (WBNA which transmits digitally on VHF Channel Eight). Many of the local Louisville folks living in the shadow of this station can not receive it with indoor, "who knows what" antennas! I am in Lexington, about 75 miles EAST of Louisville, and NEVER have problems receiving this station. Why? Because I have the right antenna (unamplified, by the way) up 50 feet to do the job. If you are trying to receive a VHF station, you need a VHF antenna....even if you are close to the station.