If anything, Star seriously needed to find some sort of direction for a fair amount of time. Over the stations six years, the station continually swayed from rhythmic oldies to rhythmic AC to a very dance-friendly rhythmic AC to a hot AC... although for some reason, every direction taken always seemed to include excessive spins of Donna Summer and the Bee Gees. The poorly-planned Richard Hatch morning gig and the revolving door of personalities at the station's start couldn't have helped listeners adjust to the station at the start either.
That said, Star was able to pull decent ratings considering that the station's rimshot status, and if Infinity/CBS had pulled the trigger on Jack FM just a day earlier, Star would probably still be around today. Star leaves a legacy in Boston - the station tested the waters for any MOViN-like stations that may come in the future, showing that a rhythmic contemporary outlet could work in a city full of rock stations - but as for whether the "Star" brand will return to the regular dial (seeing that Star lives on at 93.7 HD-2), it's probably not too likely.