If he stays anonymous, and I'm believing he hasn't because he told us he's Jack Victor and I have no evidence to believe that isn't true, and keeps posting, I'm still going to be wildly entertained because I like this stuff
And my true identity is Mister Ed...or Franklin Coslett...or Miss Nancy. I really don't give a good dump who this person actually is, but I do give a dump when someone comes here and thinks they can play us for a pack of fools, which I think is what's happening.
Entertaining? Damn right, very entertaining indeed. God knows this board could use a poke in the ass, and maybe "Jack" is providing just that.
As to discouraging thoughtful discussion, Yonk, I am clearly opposed to that - bring it on, let's go, have at it. Here's my fuel for that discussion...
1) I say "Jack" is a female. Look for the clues. I see them.
2) I say "Jack" is a print person who would love to be on the radio/TV. There are many.
3) I also say that "Jack" will before long go away. Once found out, "Jack" will split. I'm near certain who "Jack" is.
Great discussion, the best this board has seen in a long time. Keep it going.