Nick Scott said:
Back to the HD subject. When I left Q102 a couple of years ago, they had QHD and BHD (B105) up and running. I don't have an HD radio but I would assume that they are still in operation. I would love to see them fully develop these into full functioning stations with live jocks.
I have one, and those stations are still going, but I can't really tell a difference between the subchannels and the main ones. Q102's HD2 sounds like it's just Q102 minus jocks and commercials, same with B105. I don't think HD Radio has much of a chance, and if you look at the HD Radio section of these fine boards, you can tell most people on here don't. Most of it is about the interference on the AM side, however, FM has its issues as well. Ncincy1 mentioned the limited signal coverage, and this is something I've noticed too. Luckily I have a Sony XDR-S3HD which has excellent FM sensitivity. I can pick up 93.1 WIBC from Indianapolis all the time. But most radios aren't as sensitive. I've never been in a car that has HD, but I imagine that if you're driving around in the outskirts of signal range, the dropouts would be very annoying. People with cars that have HD Radios installed often go back to the dealership complaining about how bad the radios are! Not to mention that the programming isn't really special enough to justify dropping $150 plus on a new radio. Satellite has the advantage of having a nationwide signal that is more reliable, and the huge amount of programming choices. When internet radio in the car becomes more possible, it will also have the advantage of a nationwide signal plus the ability for people to listen to their favorite local stations from coast to coast. Getting favorite local stations in 64 or 128 kbps across the country sounds much better than getting them only in the city in mediocre sound quality. Just my two cents.