Will, you crazy transplanted Vermonter... You're absolutely correct - if you're looking at charts from, say, 5 years ago. This morning's chart, courtesy of MediaBase (BDS closely mirrors the same numbers, tho):
FRAY "You Found Me" # 1 Hot AC, # 9 T40
NICKELBACK "Gotta Be Somebody" # 2 Hot AC, # 25 T40
TAYLOR SWIFT "Love Story" #3 Hot AC, # 2 T40
KATY PERRY "Hot n Cold" # 4 Hot AC, #21 T40
DAVID COOK "Light On" # 5 Hot AC #29 T40
JASON MRAZ "I'm Yours" # 6 Hot AC, # 20 T40
KELLY CLARKSON "My Life..." # 7 Hot AC, # 8 T40
OAR "Shattered" # 8 Hot AC, Never worked at T40
PINK "Sober" # 9 Hot AC, # 5 Top 40
DAUGHTRY "What About Now" # 10 Hot AC, not charted T40
Doesn't look "quite distinct" to me...
If you ask JayBeau at BMX what he looks at when it comes to adding a song, 75 percent of the time he'll want to know:
1. What's its national chart position? (not really a factor if it's not in the Top 20)
2. Is Kiss (T40/CHR) on it?
Will, so I won't be totally accused of hijacking the WERZ thread, when Pete Falconi and Jack O'Brien drive the ERZ ship, they borrowed from other formats as well. Mostly rock leaning songs that ultimately crossed over to T40 (they were ahead of the curve many times) as well as some of the dancier songs (they actually played Sonny Joe White's, "Jackie Lucky."