Having worked overnights at 'SNE under Holland Cooke many moons ago...it has been tough to see and hear the transitions over there. Yeah, I think many of us agree the place needs something (and not the likes of Ryan Seacrest, ugh!)
How about PERSONALITY - LOCAL PERSONALITY??? If the right format (smooth jazz/soul/r&b with some hot gospel and salsa crossover for some spice) hit the airwaves there it would start a revolution...and add some real good personalities that relate to people and you'd have a keeper of a station you'd never turn off. You can't deny that when those Senokot laxative commercials belt out 'I Feel Good', James Brown just gets all in you...you mean you HAVEN'T spun your bath or dish towel or taken your child or beloved feline out for a dancin' spin when songs like that are on? The right airstaff doing this will WIN, WIN, WIN!!! You can't help but win to what people relate to...
Fact one: we all still love the r&b stuff and jazz found on films and Weather Channel. Many of us ask 'gee why can't this be on someplace, somewhere local, all the time?'
The angst many share about 'what to do about bad radio' comes down to simple relativity: do I or you or we relate and connect with what we hear? Many - including myself - say HELL NO. Anyone with the notion to redo what's already out there will not fix the need. Thinking back to the roots of this business and out of the box of where programmers live in seclusion is the two-pronged approach to ideas, fresh ones that many want and need to hear. That includes advertisers!
In our re-creating oldies on Juke Box Gold on WINY/Putnam, we came to consensus that our target - oldies lovers (notice NO age and sex info here???) wanted a wide mix of oldies which had recognition by the audience and the charts, but done with 'INCLUSION' rather than exclusion. Yeah, I will play Johnny Cash next to the Beatles, why? That was radio in the 60s! It's all 'oldies' with flavors of rock, r&b, jazz, country, etc...and that was the 60s music experience! This vapid segmentation we live in formatically is what makes people crabby about 'stale music' and 'old playlists'. (Oh, if you want to tune in, Sundays 6-11am on 1350AM in Putnam CT, heard OK in Providence/Worcester area and some points south, or just log in at winyradio.com and hit the listen in area).
My experiment over the years has been to mix in hits from Contemporary Christian to Hispanic to NuJazz on the IPod or computer and play this stuff where people are in earshot. They absolutely love it, often asking me 'what is this station?' I always answer: 'coming to an outlet near you someday'. When you get your real estate agent doing open houses with this stuff on, you know it's having an impact. I do the same at parties; same impact.
Programmers need to get radical here, start getting back to being educated about formats and what fits these days. They're often dogged with statistical bullpoop about 'what the trends say'...did all these trendsters ever ask you or ME about my musical taste and opinions? Whose opinions are these that they foist upon this industry anyway?
'Nuff said for now.