Lets bring this up say Q 100 was not owned by Cumulus. Say if CBS or CC owned them, would it sound the same way?
Talk_Dude said:Fact: There aren't enough people living in the Altanta Metro area who would change their radio station of choice to a CHR station to make a CHR station a profitable enterprise. So far, there are two people now calling for a CHR Station in Atlanta. There is one who lives in Arizona and who therefore doesn't mean diddly in terms of ratings points, and there's a newcomer to the region. That ain't enough people to make a CHR station a profitable operation.
Ken said:Lets bring this up say Q 100 was not owned by Cumulus. Say if CBS or CC owned them, would it sound the same way?
mike7586 said:I will admit that Q100 has gotten slightly better so there is hope, and I do like the Saturday night mix show (but it's only one day of the week unfortunately and late at night). I'm still confused as to why they are playing "indie-rock/alternative" music during the day now. I like alternative, but it doesn't belong on Q100. It just makes me wonder what the hell they are thinking?
I did some research and other Cumulus CHR's do not do this. If you look at i106 in Nashville and i93 in Dallas, they are actually pretty decent CHR's. Also, for example, they are not blasting Theory of a Deadman - Not Meant To Be or Owl City - Fireflies or John Mayer as recurrents, but more rhythmic/upbeat songs like other CHR's. They also play songs throughout the whole day (for example, Far East Movement - Like A G6). So Cumulus is capable of creating good CHR's but why not Q100? Who has more control over the playlist - Cumulus or Q100?
Also, since I have been so negative and I apologize, I will give Q100 credit in that they add MOST new music, but where I get annoyed is that they always fail to play those 3-5 new songs that are played everywhere else in the country (for example this time around, Kevin Rudolf - I Made It, Auburn - La La La and David Guetta - Gettin' Over You). Instead, they add Sick Puppies - Maybe ??? If I were some of these artists (Akon, Pitbull, David Guetta, Kevin Rudolf, Auburn, etc. because there are many more) I would be pissed my songs are not being played in a top 7 market. Also, Atlanta is the only market in the top 10 without a full blown CHR station and I have a hard time believing it can't support one. If Q100 went full blown CHR, I know their ratings would be higher and could seriously compete with V-103.
mike7586 said:Here is an email I got from Rob Roberts at Q100 in response to an email I sent about why they are playing rock/alternative songs, why they don't play certain songs, and the horrible male voice they use:
"Let me address several of these in order.
While not all of those songs appeal to everyone obviously, there is a great deal of passion in Atlanta for those rock/alternative songs that were top 5 songs on the Hot 100. We only talk/research people who listen to Q100. So the people who are responding to our research are specifically commenting on songs they want to hear on Q100. These songs in no way compete with 99X or constrict the flow of success for 99X. These are flavor songs that make a station distinct.
Talk_Dude said:mike7586 said:Here is an email I got from Rob Roberts at Q100 in response to an email I sent about why they are playing rock/alternative songs, why they don't play certain songs, and the horrible male voice they use:
"Let me address several of these in order.
While not all of those songs appeal to everyone obviously, there is a great deal of passion in Atlanta for those rock/alternative songs that were top 5 songs on the Hot 100. We only talk/research people who listen to Q100. So the people who are responding to our research are specifically commenting on songs they want to hear on Q100. These songs in no way compete with 99X or constrict the flow of success for 99X. These are flavor songs that make a station distinct.
That's one of the dumbest things I think I've ever read. Business success is about growth. It's not about remaining stagnant. The most important thing for any radio station to find out is what it would take to get the people who don't listen to your station that you can add without chasing away your current audience. People are always going to get bored with any station and stop listening eventually. Any station that doesn't do things to replace those they're going to lose anyway is doomed to eventual failure.
KDM 7000 said:...I, however, am serious about getting a certain sound there, ESPECIALLY when it has been proven that it could work in the past, but someone somewhere is just CHOOSING not to let it happen...
amos said:when i got into radio, my first PD took a handful of pens out of his desk and threw them at me while saying "catch!"
i caught none of them.
then he took one at a time and tossed them at me. i caught each one.
"one thought per break," he said. that's all the listener can catch.
KDM you say so much that nobody catches any of it.
T.G. said:Well said, Amos. Makes me glad my mouse has a scroll wheel.
mike7586 said:What I don't understand is this: people who want to hear rock/alternative are not going to tune into a top 40 station and why would they? Wouldn't you all agree?
MsMusicRadio said:Given that B98.5 sucks, it makes sense to me that a Hot AC would work and give them competition.