Now I'm more convinced than ever that "Elliot in the Morning" on WOR was a stunt.
Over at another message board someone posted: "After listening to Hilary [sic] Barsky these past few mornings, I am wondering why WOR doesn't just keep her in the spot?"
Yikes! Hilarie Barsky filled in numerous times for John Gambling and nobody paid any attention. The poster went on, " ... it is refreshing to hear a smart woman in the morning, instead of a dumb male bellowing at listeners and making not-funny jokes." Well ....... yeah! After Elliot ANYTHING would seem smart and refreshing.
I know it's only anecdotal but this is pretty good evidence that the strategy of flushing the audience works. Again, I believe Clear Channel took the most raunchy and tasteless show they had in their stable and slapped it on the air on WOR to completely flush the Gambling audience. People say the show does well in the DC area. Do we really know how well?
In summation:
1) If CC's intent was to immediately appeal to a younger audience I'm sure they could have done that with any number of hosts they already employ. They can't be dumb enough to have thought the Elliot show would fly on WOR.
2) Detractors of the "stunt" theory say they were building a new studio for him. Turns out it was only a studio renovation so that Elliot could run his own board. How long could that take? 2 or 3 days tops? OK, maybe a week?
3) CC did nothing to tailor the show to NYC, nor to promote it.
4) Detractors say Elliot didn't want to make the show more NYC-centric for fear of losing DC listeners. BS! It's not his decision. If CC wanted to take the risk they'd do it whether he liked it or not. Furthermore there was plenty of time to have that discussion before January.
5) Detractors say the sudden departure of Elliot with no one to replace him is proof that it wasn't a stunt. Really? How about maybe a major WOR advertiser issued a cancellation order, and pulling Elliot was the way to get the business back. The explanation with a dollar sign attached is usually the one you can count on.
I rest my case.