Re: Generational Music
I have to disagree a little bit. I think that the inspirational power of music shouldn't be so easily dismissed. People listen to music which celebrates and discusses immoral and violent behavior. They might not actually go out and do immoral and violent things, and here's hoping that they're not, but I think there is a very gradual wearing down of morals and standards due to all those immoral and violent messages in the music. You can stretch that to TV, to any kind of media, really.
When people listen to music, they're looking to hear from an artist that sympathizes and empathizes with them. People let these artists into their heads and, even if they don't agree with everything the artist says, they find something that they agree on. They let the artist in, they let the music in, even a little bit.
So, let's say some guy is listening to Eminem because he's ticked off at his wife/girlfriend/whatever. He probably won't throw her in a trunk and leave her to die, but he certainly identifies with Eminem's rage. He's let the music, the lyrics, in. Now he feels even more justified in his rage. The music amps that up. He's found someone who's empathized, who's had similar feelings.
That said, I'll direct this next part to musicrrr.
Why is everyone always picking on rap music? There are plenty of intelligent rap artists out there who have more things to say than just celebrations of thug culture (sorry, musicrrr, but Kanye West is one of those intelligent rap artists). And rock and roll, as others have mentioned in this thread, is loaded with negative messages. Sublime is quite violent, Puddle of Mudd and Nickelback tend towards misogyny, etc, etc...
Maybe the abandonment of rock by the radio powers-that-be has nothing to do with pushing some P.C. fantasyland on the populace. Maybe rock deserves to wane. It's gotten pretty bland since the late 90's (Creed, anyone?). It needs to go back on the fringes where it started and regroup.
> > I think you need to give today's youth more credit in
> > knowing the difference between a song lyric and a
> lifestyle.
> > Our parent's generation disliked the themes and lyrics and
>
> > lifestyle of rock music as much as rap is disliked now.
> > Some of our generation did take it seriously and burned
> out
> > on drugs or dropped out of 'normal' society, but most of
> us
> > grew up OK, and I suspect the future generations will too.
>
> > Why do suburban kids embrace this - I'd suspect many just
> to
> > shock their parents, as we did with rock music. If your
> > parents grew up on rock, you'd need to find something
> > different to shock them - that seems to happen with every
> > generation.
> >
> > I admit as a youth that I also "embraced thug music that
> > celebrated drugs, prostitution, murder and violence", and
> my
> > parents did think that my listening too much to WRCP was
> > disturbing, but I turned out OK, too. (A few examples:
> "Six
> > Days on The Road" Dave Dudley, "Cocaine Blues" Johnny
> Cash;
> > "I'm The Son of Hickory Holler's Tramp" Johnny Russell,
> "Bed
> > of Roses" Statler Brothers; "Folsom Prison Blues" Johnny
> > Cash, "Life to Go" Stonewall Jackson; "Boy Named Sue"
> Johnny
> > Cash, "Bonnie & Clyde" Merle Haggard and this doesn't
> begin
> > to mention all the drinking & cheating songs, which I
> think
> > worried my parents more. Today these are all considered
> > "country classics" Yes, I still listen to them 30+ years
> > later every day on Sirius 62 and 117 WSM and I still don't
>
> > drink, cheat, or murder.)
> >
>
> As a teen I loved bands like Ozzy, Motley Crue, Skid Row,
> Kiss, AC/DC, Priest, and some of the classic stuff like
> Floyd, ZEP, Who, Stones, etc... I understood the lyrics, I
> read the newspaper accounts of who drove who off the road
> because they were drunk/high/whatever. Who committed
> suicide based on an Ozzy song. I never did any of these
> things, nor did I think about doing any of these things
> because some dude wrote a song about it. I would really
> like to HOPE that today's youth aren't all morons who
> imitate songs on the radio. You will always have a few
> knuckleheads who imitate things they hear in songs (it was
> the same in the 60's, 70's, 80's and 90's also), but the
> majority of todays kids listening to Kanye West and robbing
> a bank, that's a little far fetched.
>