J
Jersey Maiden
Guest
hubcity said:Barry said:While I agree that it makes sense to have a format on HD2 that is different from the main channel, it seems redundant for 97.1 HD2 to play alternative/modern rock, when there are already three other HD subchannels devoted to the format. But perhaps Emmis is trying to keep the 'RXP brand around, in case they want to bring it back somehow. CBS may be thinking the same thing with K-Rock, on 92.3 HD2.
But where else can one get one's alternative rock mixed with Van Halen and AC/DC?
/feel free to let the boneheadedness of that statement sink in. I really don't get it.
WMMR from Philly is another place where you can get it (though they're mainly active rock and in the top 5 for their market). And for those of us who want an active/alternative hybrid, RXP's playlist doesn't go far enough (the only active rock they play are classics). While they're still better than a lot of mainstream HD1 stations, their playlist somehow manages to have the worst of both worlds. It takes some effort to have "out of place" songs while maintaining a narrow, bland mix overall. And yet I'll be jumping for joy if that came back to HD1. Better than have no rock in the city at all. I'm sure my co-worker from Philly would be laughing at me for having such low standards for radio.
I also think commercial stations are getting a clue that their HD2s should be completely different than their HD1s, so that HD2 listeners know they've dropped back to HD1 when it happens, and they don't cannibalize their FM/HD1 listeners by putting a complimentary format on HD2. MyRXP makes sense from that perspective, though frankly its playlist makes no sense.
Yes, their HD2 is a different genre than their HD1 but again, MyRXP is just as generic as that of your average conventional station. It makes no sense to make the playlist for their HD2 version more narrow.