Dave-FM is definitely competing against them (they're playing Breakeven, If It's Love, King Of Anything, Animal, and gold tracks by Matchbox 20, Fastball, Tonic, Goo Goo Dolls, Lifehouse, etc.)
The new Star 94 PD is choosing to concentrate on playing familiar songs, and he's got the narrowest playlist I think the station's ever had (the currents/recurrents are STILL frozen, except for the two new songs he added) - IMO if Dave-FM is still beating them in January, that's gonna be a problem
I'd like to think PDs don't let their personal experiences dictate what they do, but this guy has an AC background, and he's programming Star like an AC - the last guy came from WAPE, a CHR which spun its powers 100x a week, and the first thing he did was increase Star's powers to 100x a week - just seems like PDs are doing what worked for them in the past on other stations, rather than what's best for Star 94 in its current situation