April is a low panel churn month. The peak churns are November, December and July-August due to lifestyle issues.Look at the oscillations in those numbers. KCBS goes from a 6.0 to an 8.0 in one month? More likely the 4 month average, ~7.0, is approximately right. (KCBS suddenly gains an additional 2 share points in March, a 33% increase overnight, and then loses a third of that increase in the April survey?)
KQED, whose schedule is heavy with NPR and NPR-distributed programming, as well as APM, PRI, PRX stuff, has a loyal listener base, so how likely is it to have dropped 25% from January to February, and then gotten back half that drop in March? What's much more likely is PPM panelist churn. This particular combo of panelists must prefer the "touch-and-go" approach to news (headlines, short actualities, brief canned pieces from their reporters, traffic & weather together and lots & lots of commercials), and is less friendly to the mighty 'QED's longform programming.
Haven't seen those breakouts, but it sure looks bad based on 6+. 11th place in San Jose with several consecutive months of decline. Way down to 23rd in SF? This is not where that station should be. (and not where they were as a Classic Hits.) This was a botched format change, with some bad decisions made. No local morning show, tracked jocks, dull presentation, clearly done "on the cheap." Nowhere near as local sounding or engaging as KRTY.How do KBAY's 25-54 and 18-49 shares with country compare to those earned by KRTY during its final six months or so as an FM country station?
They should’ve never flipped to country. How can skinny jean flannel wearing hipsters in the Bay relate to growing up on farms, $2 beer and being raised in baptist churches?Haven't seen those breakouts, but it sure looks bad based on 6+. 11th place in San Jose with several consecutive months of decline. Way down to 23rd in SF? This is not where that station should be. (and not where they were as a Classic Hits.) This was a botched format change, with some bad decisions made. No local morning show, tracked jocks, dull presentation, clearly done "on the cheap." Nowhere near as local sounding or engaging as KRTY.
They should’ve never flipped to country. How can skinny jean flannel wearing hipsters in the Bay
Have you ever been to Manteca?relate to growing up on farms, $2 beer and being raised in baptist churches?
Agreed. The last few months of KRTY it looked like they had some huge numbers in San Jose from a handful of meter holders, giving them some great looking short-term ratings. Alpha's mistake with KBAY was looking at those numbers and thinking that this was somehow a permanent change in taste or demographics. It was not; it was a typical Nielsen short-term fluctuation. So they dumped what has been a historically more successful format in the Bay Area and blew up a station that had been #1 in San Jose for much of the past several years. Strange move.They should’ve never flipped to country. How can skinny jean flannel wearing hipsters in the Bay relate to growing up on farms, $2 beer and being raised in baptist churches?
Do they put mud tires on their 2006 F150s in Manteca?Oh, that's so 2018.
Have you ever been to Manteca?
It just doesn’t make sense. They would’ve been better off flipping to alternativeAgreed. The last few months of KRTY it looked like they had some huge numbers in San Jose from a handful of meter holders, giving them some great looking short-term ratings. Alpha's mistake with KBAY was looking at those numbers and thinking that this was somehow a permanent change in taste or demographics. It was not; it was a typical Nielsen short-term fluctuation. So they dumped what has been a historically more successful format in the Bay Area and blew up a station that had been #1 in San Jose for much of the past several years. Strange move.
Not in sales...It just doesn’t make sense. They would’ve been better off flipping to alternative
Thus far in 2023 (Jan-Apr), KBAY has averaged 0.2 shares below the average KRTY had in 2021 (Jan-Nov) prior to the anomalous few months it had to start off 2022.How do KBAY's 25-54 and 18-49 shares with country compare to those earned by KRTY during its final six months or so as an FM country station?
Does country do well sales wise in Bay Area over Hot AC/classic hits?Not in sales...
I’m not from SF! It’s that good?Thus far in 2023 (Jan-Apr), KBAY has averaged 0.2 shares below the average KRTY had in 2021 (Jan-Nov) prior to the anomalous few months it had to start off 2022.
Put another way... (and this is the San Jose book, not the SF book) KRTY was 6th during the span of Jan-Nov '21, KBAY is tied for 7th so far in Jan-Apr '23.I’m not from SF! It’s that good?