I seem to like the new 106.5 The Lake so far. The station has some potential as I think it will go through some tweaking. I like that they got rid of the "Mix" name, as it seems they want to start over with a new identity as opposed to continuing with the format or tweaking as "Mix." This leaves Q104 as the only Hot AC in Cleveland. Come to think of it, Q104 is a much truer Hot AC compared to 106.5, which always seemed to had adjust their playlist, yet keeping the 80's in some way.
"Mix" had an up-and-down roller coaster ride for the past 13 years. Was great - Randy James as PD with a different type of variety/AC station along with great imaging, was not great - WMMS PD Jim Trapp (?) running "Mix" as the station lost a lot of steam, was great again - Dave Popovich breathing life with an improved playlist and sound, was still great - Don Hallett takes over to keep the station going and it wasn't too bad, was not-so-great again - OM Kevin Metheny takes over and the station is
there, was not great again - Chris Miller takes over and...replaced Brian and Joe with Valentine following mass cuts and...that's it as he never got much of a chance when got let go after not even a year (he also programmed WGAR), was great again - Tony Matteo seemed to have wanted the station to get some buzz in Cleveland with the all-Christmas format and now the new format. The Christmas music worked as it beat WDOK in overall cume, and tied with them in second place in overall numbers. That's just my assessment of "Mix."
The new station might pose as a threat to Radio 92.3, WNCX, WDOK, Q104, and to a lesser extent, V107.3. There would be those who are looking for music with little to no personality. Look at Radio 92.3. I bet a lot of people weren't sure it would succeed given the different incarnations of Alternative Rock that station went through (92.3 Xtreme Radio, 923X, 92.3 K-Rock), and not to mention trying to be another version of WMMS with the awkward Active Rock music before become a jockless, straight-up Alternative Rock station. As a result, the station is doing well.
Maybe the same thing could be for 106.5 The Lake. They could be Cleveland's version of Fly 92.9 in Dayton. In fact, here's the Yes.com playlist for Fly 92.9:
http://www.yes.com/#WGTZ?log. A lot of the music is almost similar to WMVX.
Maybe also Gen-X might've worked, but I don't think Cleveland radio wants to go through another hot format after the Jammin' Oldies mess with the old WZJM back in 1999.
That station was meant to steal listeners from stations including the now-former Mix. It didn't work as "The Beat" never fully caught on. The playlist was limited, mixing disco with Motown and little else was bad, having a poor jock line-up, and the name was just generic. The station also went through jocks who came and went. It was not a good station, and 92.3 was the wrong station to flip. It is one of the biggest mistakes of all time. That's also part of why Jack-FM, Free-FM, Fresh, and other newer formats never made it to Cleveland.
There still could be room for 90's-oriented music. I personally think it should be mixed in with the newer music on Q104, and make it like a Gen-X/Hot AC hybrid. Heck, if The Lake takes off, and if WMMS wants to adjust their rock playlist (which they
really should), maybe WNCX could go Alternative and 92.3 going some type of Rhythmic CHR format (bring back the "Jammin'" name too), though that would mean Q104 would have to adjust...and so would V107.3. That's just wishful thinking.
In the meantime, I think the new 106.5 might take off given some time and a chance to polish. I love it
waaaaaaaaaay better than the "No Rules" period for "Mix." That got old really quick and didn't last. Best of luck to 106.5 The Lake.