Very interesting topic everyone. Josh, I appreciate your enthusiasm, as well as the input of current and former owners and Goat Rodeo Cowboy. I am aware of stand alone AMs that work. Locally, a gentleman purchased a daytimer 20 miles from a top 75 market and did classic country, anything from old bluegrass to 80s, Tradio, and other down home programming. He did well enough with local direct advertising to buy two more daytimers in the surrounding area, which he mostly simulcasts (I think he may be able to feed separate spots to them). He even hired a popular morning talent that Clear Channel had let go. Now one of the daytimers has an FM translator that just went on the air. I'm referring to WBZI 1500 in Xenia, OH; WKFI 1090 in Wilmington, OH; and WEDM 1130 in Eaton, OH. (WEDM is the former WCTM, which Stan Coning ran as a Beautiful Music station into his 80s).
I'm also aware of WANO and WFXY in Middlesboro, KY. They are a local success story. The very young previous owner was featured as part of "30 under 30" in radio. He sold them and apparently did well enough to enjoy life a little before he makes his next career move.
Having said that....I'm aware of a few situations with stand alone AMs that are just disasters. One in particular has bankrupted more than one owner. There's a daytimer near Cincinnati that is now silent waiting for something to happen. Alchemy Broadcasting still can't find the financing to close the deal on WCIN in Cincinnati, where they are LMAing their oldies format. I struggled in a losing battle to keep an AM in Springfield, OH afloat, which fortunately I didn't own.
As for me...owning stations was something I always wanted to do, but it never happened for me. Of course, I may have gone bankrupt the first month with the very little business experience I had had. I often wondered if I had taken that route, when the consolodators were coming around with those big, fat checks..let's say I'd be on a beach where it's 80 degrees, not sitting in Ohio.
Today, even assuming I could find financing, I'm not so sure. There certainly are opportunities like I mentioned somewhere, but then again there are situations like a West Virginia station that became somewhat of a joke on the internet, because the trailer and run down van were included, that finally went to a religious group for $60,000. With one of these stations, would it be a matter of making an investment or buying a job? More than likely the big boys, or a new set of medium boys, aren't going to be coming around and buying every tower in sight like in the consolodation feeding frenzy. Even EMF (the K-Love people), gets rid of an AM that comes with an FM as soon as possible. Now, coming with 5 acres of land, assuming it wasn't swampland in Florida, might make it an investment for the land value. Get tired of radio, sell it to a strip mall developer. I don't see how you'd buy a few daytimers or graveyarders and leverage them to buy a medium market cluster of FMs. The last hope for many of these stations is a religious broadcaster picking them up, either for screaming fire and brimstone brokered programming or Catholic radio. Many towns that could have been viable years ago are now bedroom communities to large cities, and the chain restaurants and stores aren't advertising on ex-urban facilities.
I'm thinking my future career lies in helping businesses carve out their own piece of digital real estate with new media. Part of it is not wanting to be tied to one area 365 days a year. As for Part 15ers buying one of these stations, you'd better be prepared to be morning host, sales manager, engineer, janitor, IT professional and general maintenance man. You'll also have to program what will work in that situation, and it may well be Southern Gospel and not the 10,000 unknown songs on your iPod that you assume everyone wants to hear.
And finally, some of those stations in the 70s were real trips. Wasn't looking to buy any then, but looking for my first job. Remember one where they copied songs off Wolfman Jack or AT40, cut the intros off and put them on a reel to get their music.