thirdendorsed said:
Maynard was one of the all time great performers on Boston radio. But let us clear up a few things.
First, no program director assigned Maynard to the overnight. At the time, WBZ was running behind WHDH in the ratings. It was soon after WHDH had switched from MOR to AC, livened up its news, broomed the old style talent in favor of jocks with Top 40 experience. added the 'HDH Payphone diary reminder promotion, and bent over backwards to hold its core in Boston and the inner suburbs -- capitalizing on its Voice of the City legacy. Blair even bought a full page ad in the Globe a few weeks after the '78 blizzard to tout that its Accu-weather had been alone in the market in forecasting that an expected major storm would be a bust.
Westinghouse Chairman Don McGannon decided to make a change in Boston for business and personal reasons. He broomed the general manager and installed Bill Hartman. Hartman immediately ripped into the complacent attitude, telling the staff they had better quit walking around like they were number one in the market because they weren't. As much to hammer the point home as anything, Hartman, not some program director, moved Maynard to overnights. David was not pleased. If there are any tapes of his first shift, they are a classic because he spent the night ripping management. Maynard was told he'd be pulled off the air for his contract and his non-compete and "we'll see how hot you are when nobody's heard you for a few years." Things settled down and Hartman brought the station back to No. 1.
If you think program directors decided who is going to be the morning drive talent at a 50-clear in the 7-7-7 era, you are out of your mind. Those decisions were make a lot higher in the food chain.
Wow, so much misinformation in this thread. Let's start with "as big as he thought he was." Maynard was one of the nicest guys on the station, and by far the nicest morning show host I ever dealt with. His ego was far less than most, and I know because I dealt with him daily.
Chris Cross had nothing to do with putting Maynard on the overnight, he wasn't even there at the time. And he wasn't "let go", I asked for him to be transferred to KDKA, where I was moved as GM after serving as WBZ's program director during the DeSuze/Maynard transition. (It may be true that Chris wasn't well liked; he was the disciplinarian in the management ranks, a thankless job without which we would not have succeeded. I give him a large measure of credit for handling the talk shows, producers, and various other jobs behind the scenes, as well as doing quite creditable fill in talk show duties for both Dave Finnegan and Larry Glick.)
Last, Maynard was moved to the overnight because Bill Hartmann was trying to cut costs. The AFTRA contract required a 'buy out' if you were letting someone of long tenure go (IIRC it would have been around $50k) and Hartman didn't want to pay it. Someone else left (voluntarily, no payout), I forget who, and Hartman stretched the shifts to eliminate one shift. That left DeSuze in the morning, Bob Raleigh in Midday, and Bruce Bradley in the overnight. Maynard was the logical one to do a talk show, because he COULD. (Raleigh did, and was OK, Bruce was talented but he was a bit too rapid and spicy for overnight.) I followed that PD (Dave Martin) but yes, Hartmann made the change, not because "McGannon wanted to shake things up" but because the station was faltering, the ratings were slipping and the profitability plummeting. That's what a GM is supposed to do.
Changing the morning man is one of the biggest moves you can make on one of these heritage AM's, and corporate (New York) was terrified of the prospect. So were we. If you lose the morning you've lost the whole station, plus Hartman didn't want to have to pay off DeSuze. (When we finally made the change he forced me to move him to midday and save that payout, which was a disaster.)
Anyway, our choices for a DeSuze replacement were Bruce Bradley or Dave Maynard. I voted 50/50, either guy, Hartmann wanted Maynard. He was right, Maynard was great, worked hard, came to work with a day's full of "quips" written on several pages of a legal, yellow lined pad, and worked them into the show - along with the banter of the rest of the team, notably Gary LaPierre and Gil Santos. (Joe Green and Don Kent were also great in their roles, but not in the kibbitzing department.)
Few people remember, but Dave was not successful for the first 18 months; an agency did a TV spot which fell flat, and with DeSuze as his lead out the show barely improved over DeSuze's numbers, and the midday sank, so overall we were not really better. It wasn't until the "Maynard In The Morning" TV spots came about, and Carl was moved to a desk job and replaced by Ron Robin that the station took off. Dave's numbers increased aplenty, middays came back, and the station rose from a weak #3 to a strong #1, eclipsing the rise of Jess Cain and WHDH, where the exceptional GM and PD (Dave Croninger and Al Brady) had put together a well oiled machine and were on track to take over the "heritage" mantle from the faltering WBZ.
Thank goodness for those TV spots, they really did the trick. Maybe someday I'll tell the story, but it will likely take even longer than this!