SuperRadioFan said:
Channel Flipper, you've always made some great points, what specifically would you do if Bonneville tapped you on the shoulder and said: "Mr ChannelFlipper, you're our new PD of 100.3 The Sound, go to it!" ?
Thanks for the compliment. The question is fair but yet loaded - because as I mentioned the other day, the station's overall success is actually not related to the quality of the programming. That is, the best programmed AAA station simply cannot generate sufficient ratings based on the demographics of the MSA they are servicing. The best they could hope for is to do something compelling yet mainstream enough to at least generate some ratings that would keep it in existence for as long as possible (knowing that even in the best case scenario, you are probably just looking at a few years at best before management wises up and changes format or sells the signal). It is a narrow range to work in.
I've shared in the past that the best station ever was KMPC-FM/KEDG-FM in 1988-1989. Artistically/styalistically speaking they would be the model. They had DJs with distinct personalities, and allowed their personalities to show through without getting in the way of the format, even allowing them to pick a few of their own cuts per shift. It was clear they all enjoyed working there for JJ and the station was really upbeat and fun. The music was about as wide-ranging as the format would allow. Lots of new artists exposed while also throwing in enough classic rock to keep it familiar enough to stay tuned in through the unfamiliar stuff and the classic rock tracks were not burned over and over as the Sound does.
However a copy of KMPC/KEDG would not work either (much to my chagrin!). In order to have any success with the AAA format, the new songs and artists have to be tightly controlled in much the same way a top 40 station is. Actually, I thought KSCA did a pretty good job of that when they were on the air. They introduced new artists, but not so many that they got lost in the shuffle - and thus with heavy rotation, the new artists and songs gained some familiarity to the core listening audience. For example through heavy airplay of a couple of tracks, they turned me on to Southern Culture on the Skids, a great fun band that I would have never been exposed to without them. The tight repetition may not make heavy users of the station like us happy, but the vast majority of the audience in this format are not heavy users of the station. The station would still also need a significant portion of classic rock tracks to make it accessible for the audience, but they don't have to pick the same six Supertramp tunes over and over. I think it was Scooty who came up with at least 10 great Supertramp tracks that the Sound doesn't play, nearly all of which the audience knows just as well as the ones they burn to death.
OK, what the station should not do. Quit telling the audience how cool you are because you play some tracks that haven't been on the radio a lot. It's insulting to the audience and I cringe every time I hear it. Don't tell people you are cool, just be cool. Does Fonzi have to tell Richie and the gang how much cooler he is than they are every time they meet at Arnold's? No. He doesn't need to say anything. He just is cooler, and everyone else is smart enough to figure this out without any words said. Same concept. Just do it, don't tell me about it.
Keep the specialty shows and gimicks out of the standard weekday listening hours. Most listeners to this station are casual listeners and they don't know what to expect when they get "Deeper Cuts" told to them one day, a full album side including album cuts they never heard before on another, and a stupid "which album "wins and advances to the next round" on another day. If I don't know what is coming next and I am a regular listener, what is a new casual listener to make of this? Their daytime programming is a mess in this regard. As David E. said, if you have to have specialty shows, put them on the fringe weekend hours where they will minimize their harm. The 10@10 should be kept though. It is a popular feature on other stations and can really show some station character if done right.
Lastly, this station is in desperate need of some personality. The station sounds like it is a serious station for serious listeners, even with their gimicks. Even though they rock more now because of the Led Zep and other classic rock they have added, it still feels like a Starbucks experience. This may be what the audience wants, but the DJs and imaging are simply yawnsville. Station has no energy to it. I'm not saying you have to have Frazier Smith in the morning (please no, in fact) but do something to liven up the pulse. Make me feel like if I don't tune in, I might be missing something. This is how I felt with KMPC/KEDG.
There are other issues of imaging, advertising, web management,and community involvement that Glenn has commented on that need serious repair as well, but my response is limited to simply what is heard on the air. And again, I don't pretend to have the magic touch to fix this station nor are any of my suggestions indicative of any brilliant insight, but they can easily improve the station a lot from where it is.
OK, that's my two cents.