Having only posted once before I'm usually content to watch the comings and goings of others as they take their sides and flaunt their expertise. Because I spend most of my time in Mecklenberg County, I'm not as up to date with the WRDU vs. WPTF debate as those here. But it seems everyone is missing the point. Is it really any surprise a station with the top three syndicated talkers, moved to the FM band, with a nice cume infusion from Carolina basketball would beat the pants off stodgy old WPTF? How could they not? Like most of the mid-market talk stations that still live on the AM band, WPTF was, first and foremost, a conservative talk station, not a news outlet. It's pretty tough to carry that standard when you don't have any of the big three righty talkers on your air. Considering all the foolish moves by Clear Channel in Raleigh (WTRG to WRVA, WRSN to WKSL, WRDU Rock to WRDU Country), I'd say it's about damn time they got something right.
I think the bigger question is how WPTF is responding. I'm in town this weekend and what I heard yesterday on 680 AM was damned impressive. They are not in the same league with WBT or WSB yet, but they have come farther in the last couple of months then they did in the last couple of decades. Do I think they'll swing back around and clobber WRDU? Hardly. Certainly not in the current turbocharged political environment. But anyone here who calls themselves a true broadcaster--and I don't claim to be--has to admire the resources WPTF is putting up to stay viable. Whoever posted that the incoming PPM will likely drive down WRDU's TSL is correct. Those right-wing zealots with a diary are surely overreporting their enthusiasm for the station. And the cume will stagnate at some point. Meanwhile 680 is playing to cume by driving more news usage, and that should ulitamtely pay off when PPM comes along based on what I've read. The battle is fun to watch. But anyone who thinks its over after one book is oversimplifying the whole thing. Or they probably work for Clear Channel. Come on Randy...lighten up. As one of the great programming warriors have to be pulling for the underdog, aren't you?